Herochat

Comicsgate

therock

  • ********
  • 8598
  • +43/-65
    • View Profile
Re: Comicsgate
« Reply #240 on: July 27, 2018, 10:39:39 AM »
So he's a hack if he has never disagreed with someone else about what constitutes SJW content. That's a pretty ridiculous definition for a hack.

I've pointed out that on at least two occasions, he's praised the work of creators who openly ally with SJW politics and/or disagree with his opinions. He's also been very complimentary of the past work of Mark Waid, who is probably his biggest opponent in comic books. A hack wouldn't do that.

Yea kind of. I lean liberal but I can point out where liberals being dicks or where they are wrong

We both agree...that people on BOTH sides all not always right. Not being able to point that out..to be is being a bit of a hack

For example if your for freedom of speech no matter what and your go against say the Duck Dyansty guy being fired, or Think Ted Nudget got a right to say what ever he want that good. But if your also ok with say Kathy Griffin being fired...then your kind of a hack. Or if your a liberal who does the same thing in the reverse

Or another instance I probally wouldnt fire Rosane or james gunn. Since in both instance could of rode it out, and they knew about their comments before they hired them. I have a luxury of saying this becuase I dont run a youtube channel. What if no big sjw news in comics happens in the next 3 months. You think he will go "Look like we won guys..welp no news on that front today".  Or will he pick out a small thing or iffy thing and maybe blow it up a few extra proportions

Not just basing this on the shera thing...basiing it on his other videos. Where he said heroes being replace..when they werent that many being replace. Among other things. Now if people think I should see MORE of his videos before I make a judgement. Note I saw more episodes of his show...then he saw of Shera when he made the  "This is a part of liberal againt beuty" statement

MTL76

  • ********
  • 10018
  • +1126/-119
  • "What if I know all your secrets, Your Eminence?"
    • View Profile
Re: Comicsgate
« Reply #241 on: July 27, 2018, 11:58:27 AM »
Do you have any thoughts about D&C praising the work of creators he considers SJWs, who identify as progressive, and who have openly and vociferously repudiated him? Does that affect your opinion of him as a hack?


Minority Shareholder, Combine Honnete Ober Advancer Mercantiles (CHOAM)

The Create A Team / Power Set Combo Compendium

therock

  • ********
  • 8598
  • +43/-65
    • View Profile
Re: Comicsgate
« Reply #242 on: July 27, 2018, 07:31:19 PM »
Do you have any thoughts about D&C praising the work of creators he considers SJWs, who identify as progressive, and who have openly and vociferously repudiated him? Does that affect your opinion of him as a hack?

sure give him some credit

basicly again equlivant of saying hey I like China town but Roman a piece of shit. that not saying much or going against the grain. I hate trump but his casino was nice. that not a huge standard for being fair and balance

but when it come up with an issue of if something an SJW agenda he will take the ItS an agenda because that his gimmick. and that a hack because it cant always be case where the anti is right just like they cant always be wrong. it got to be sometime where a short hair girl is an art choice and not part a vast feminazi agenda

but he never takes that stance


going to guess future videos

the cast for the charlies Angel's reboot cast show Hollywood against beauty and is feminist agenda to emasculate men

his review  of the captain movie will be along the lines of COURSE the most powerful hero is a woman who has to save the day after the men failed.  never mind there were women on that team that failed with them

will be happy in the future if I'm wrong. could be but more the likely I wont

Upper_Krust

  • *****
  • 1287
  • +15/-55
    • View Profile
Re: Comicsgate
« Reply #243 on: July 29, 2018, 10:44:45 AM »
sure give him some credit

basicly again equlivant of saying hey I like China town but Roman a piece of shit. that not saying much or going against the grain. I hate trump but his casino was nice. that not a huge standard for being fair and balance

but when it come up with an issue of if something an SJW agenda he will take the ItS an agenda because that his gimmick. and that a hack because it cant always be case where the anti is right just like they cant always be wrong. it got to be sometime where a short hair girl is an art choice and not part a vast feminazi agenda

but he never takes that stance

He doesn't take that stance because of how rarely we see Conservative values (or creators) represented in mainstream entertainment today.

As has already been stated though he does often praise creators for good work even if those creators have publicly denounced him.

Quote
going to guess future videos

the cast for the charlies Angel's reboot cast show Hollywood against beauty and is feminist agenda to emasculate men

First I'd heard about it so I checked it out and the more likely stance (Comicsgater's will take) is alongside the Feminist Agenda to undermine and shame beautiful women for using that beauty to make money. The left is anti-attractiveness.

So this one is nothing about emasculation and more about abandoning classical beauty*.

*As with Star Wars, Star Trek, She-Ra, Thundercats Roar, Captain Marvel etc.

Quote
his review  of the captain movie will be along the lines of COURSE the most powerful hero is a woman who has to save the day after the men failed.  never mind there were women on that team that failed with them

I think it sort of depends HOW this gets handled. If Captain Marvel is just a complete Mary Sue then I'd expect the criticism to be very vocal.

Added to which Brie Larson hasn't done herself any favours with certain comments she made recently where she gave a nice big FU to "white men".

Quote
will be happy in the future if I'm wrong. could be but more the likely I wont.

I think you will be right, but the fact that you can even predict these issues arising shows how easy it is to pick out these things.