Herochat

Which character was more impressive in these two scenes only ? Khan or Vader

Tarugo

  • *****
  • 1832
  • +0/-0
    • View Profile
So this thread is about objective not the scene comparison?

I guess this should be... which is more impressive...

Vader failing to retrieve the DS plans or Khan giving himself up to the Enterprise crew
Khan accomplished his objective in the scene.  He saved the enterprise crew and later gave himself up to manipulate the crew.  Vader failed utterly.  Khan easily decimated the Klingons according to Kirk singlehandedly.

That's why you better edit your thread as now you keep on flagging "objective" forgetting your own thread objective.

This has become:

Quan: Who is more handsome in their younger days, Brad Pitt or Tom Cruise?
:
:
Quan: Tom got divorced earlier so he loses compared to Pitt.
Nothing Is Impossible - Batman!


Quan_the_Antagonist

  • ********
  • 7125
  • +1/-2
  • Maul
    • View Profile
Vader would casually kill those two weaklings.
False.  He couldn't even get plans from fearless wills fleeing in terror despite his powers.  He's an incompetent loser.  He's also dead.  Loser.

GeneralPresidentSkeletor

  • ********
  • 28868
  • +48/-15
  • "He speaks so well!" - white people, everywhere
    • View Profile
Vader looked more impressive. Khan had the benefit of an ambush and superior firepower at his disposal, as well as aid in the form of Kirk and crew.

Vader on the other hand, casually walked into an entrenched position without the benefit of cover, making an absolute mockery of the rebels defenses.

Moving the goalposts on the purpose of the thread (determining whom looked more impressive, not whether they achieved their "objective") only further shows that Vader looked more impressive, because you're now trying to make it about anything BUT that.

Quan_the_Antagonist

  • ********
  • 7125
  • +1/-2
  • Maul
    • View Profile
Vader looked more impressive. Khan had the benefit of an ambush and superior firepower at his disposal, as well as aid in the form of Kirk and crew.

Vader on the other hand, casually walked into an entrenched position without the benefit of cover, making an absolute mockery of the rebels defenses.

Moving the goalposts on the purpose of the thread (determining whom looked more impressive, not whether they achieved their "objective") only further shows that Vader looked more impressive, because you're now trying to make it about anything BUT that.
Khan wasn't working in coordination with the crew.  Plus he had to deal with Nuuk ole
Ships as well as greater numbers and greater skilled opponents than the rebels.  The scenes are attached with success or failure as much as you'd like to distance yourself from that it's there regardless. 


Vader and his skills were there to steal the plans for the Death Star.  He could have used his powers at any point to pull the disk out of the guys hand.  Khan used his skills to save the crew and annihilate the klingons. 

GeneralPresidentSkeletor

  • ********
  • 28868
  • +48/-15
  • "He speaks so well!" - white people, everywhere
    • View Profile
Vader looked more impressive. Khan had the benefit of an ambush and superior firepower at his disposal, as well as aid in the form of Kirk and crew.

Vader on the other hand, casually walked into an entrenched position without the benefit of cover, making an absolute mockery of the rebels defenses.

Moving the goalposts on the purpose of the thread (determining whom looked more impressive, not whether they achieved their "objective") only further shows that Vader looked more impressive, because you're now trying to make it about anything BUT that.
Khan wasn't working in coordination with the crew.  Plus he had to deal with Nuuk ole
Ships as well as greater numbers and greater skilled opponents than the rebels.  The scenes are attached with success or failure as much as you'd like to distance yourself from that it's there regardless. 


Vader and his skills were there to steal the plans for the Death Star.  He could have used his powers at any point to pull the disk out of the guys hand.  Khan used his skills to save the crew and annihilate the klingons. 

Guy, nobody agrees with you. You have not convinced anyone. The question was "Who looked more impressive?" and you got your answer. Hold that L to your chest, homie.